Skip to main content

BAD Graphs

 Hi All,

Kids love to find other people's mistakes. (Not always that keen on finding their own of course.) Here's a chance for them to find some mistakes while learning some things about graphs.

This activity focuses on learning about graphs and the parts of a graph that are important, but are sometimes neglected. When kids make their own graphs the most common omissions are: the title (what is this a graph of?), labeling the x and y axis (what do numbers and bars means?), and the units (how much of what?).

A great way to remind kids of the importance of these elements is to have them try to deal with graphs that don't have them ie; BAD graphs. 

I give students a worksheet on which I have created four BAD graphs. They are BAD graphs because I leave off important elements like the title. Along with this students are also given a 4 item question sheet which they are to try to answer using the BAD graphs. I put the BAD graphs on the board or display. They look like this:

 


I play it straight and ask them to do their best work. They quickly realize it is impossible. Questions and complaints emerge and I then ask why is it impossible? What do you need to know? We proceed to correct the BAD graphs one graph at a time.

As students tell me what is missing from each graph I fill in those missing components on the board until the questions can be answered correctly. So the graphs when complete and correct will look like this. 


 

We discuss how important it was to have those easy to overlook elements like titles and how without them we don't even know what we are looking at. Graphs, after all, a way to communicate and share information. A very efficient and effective way when done right.

I then give them a sheet with some data about a lemonade stand sale and ask them to apply what they have learned and make a GOOD graph. 


These are fun to make up yourself too. Enjoy! Here's are links to the reproducibles.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1MDu7uGiFQamdFnQuTWFWX36gBwdynym6/view?usp=sharing

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1cQM7Akv9pLKBB4k16AaGF74DyfWMhlRr/view?usp=sharing

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1q3CazxAWmmbeBISYXtMG6LhsfeWDc5Wc/view?usp=sharing

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1GuMFB7Pn2I1aRa6Q0h_lCWZHHryis67R/view?usp=sharing

Best,

Bob

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Piaget Would be Proud! Assessment, Mental Math, Manipulatives, Thinking, Missing Addends, and Kumquats!

 Hi All, This is a super simple, but very revealing activity and so works as a good assessment. Fantastic for Pre-K, Kindergarten, and Grade 1. Try it out and see what you learn about your students. Display a small number of objects in your open hands. Here we have 4 kumquats. (Because I have a kumquat tree in my yard. Any small manipulative will do.) Put your hands behind your back. Close one hand and bring both hands back out in front of you to display 2 kumquats visible in one hand and a closed hand with the rest of them. Remind students that you started with 4 and there are still 4 all together. Ask students, what is in the closed hand. Ask how they know this. Then reveal and discuss. Try another one. Show the 4 objects again, 2 in each hand. Put your hands behind your back and redistribute with 1 object in one hand and 3 objects in the other. Bring your hands to the front and ask how many are in your closed hand. Ask how they know this.  Then reveal and discuss.   Yo...
Post a Comment
Read more

What Does Not Belong?

 Hi All,   "What Does Not Belong" is such a great little concept and can be applied to so many different areas of math as well as other content areas. Great little game when you are waiting, like for buses to be called or for the day to begin. Also a great game for long car or bus rides where if there are no written numbers or pictures you really have to do the mental math. Present a group of numbers. Start with maybe six. Say, 10     56     17     122     4     98 Ask the players to identify which number does not belong and have them explain why. We want players to look at the characteristics of the numbers and compare them to try to find the selection criteria or "rule" so they can determine which does not belong. For example, we have a mix of 1, 2, and 3 digit numbers, so it's not the "rule" is not the number of digits. We have five even numbers and only one odd number. That's it! 17 does not belong,...
2 comments
Read more

Fe, Fi, Fo, Fum? No! FIDDLE, FADDLE, FLOP!

Hi All, Ready for another great game? Ready for Fiddle, Faddle, Flop? It's a great game for place value, mental math, and number work. You can play anywhere at any time. All you need is a pencil and paper or board and markers. Tell students that you are thinking of a number. Explain that it has two digits. Invite them to guess the number. You will respond to their guesses by saying one of four words: Fiddle, Faddle, Flop, or Correct. Here is the translation for those words: Fiddle: one of the digits is correct, but is in the wrong place Faddle: one of the digits is correct and in the correct place Flop: none of the digits is correct Correct: both digits are correct For example, if you are thinking of the number 17 and my guess is 68, you would say Flop since none of the digits is correct. On your next guess, if you were to say 76, I would say, Fiddle, because one of the digits is correct, but in the wrong...
Post a Comment
Read more