Skip to main content

WHO'S LEFT STANDING? A PATTERN EXPLORATION!

Hi All,

Today's problem/activity is called WHO'S LEFT STANDING? It's based on playing a simple game, but has lots of intriguing patterns to investigate. You can use this activity with Grades 2 -12. Young kids will see the mathematical patterns emerge as they play while older kids will see the same and may even be able to express what they find algebraically.

The game is simple. Kind of a "Duck, Duck, Goose." If you were to have a few people get in a line and then start with the first person on the left and say, "in," and the next person, "out," the first person stays standing and the second sits down in place. 

You continue down the line alternating each person as "in" or "out." When you reach the end of the line, you go back to the beginning to the first person still standing and continue till only one person is left standing. Played with two players, #1 would be left standing. In the photos here, you can see when played with four, #1 is left standing. How about with 12 players? or 53? Who would be left standing?

Depending on the number of people playing, could you always predict who would be left standing? It helps to keep track of the numbers and how they relate to each other.  
Since you probably don't have a bunch of people to play this, you can use any physical thing to replace people like plastic cups, cans, or dominoes. When numbers get too big you can just draw rows of circles and cross them out.
But even drawing circles gets tedious when you try to work with numbers like 125. Is there a mathematical way to predict the outcome? Patterns help us predict. In this problem, the pattern at first seems very predictable, but then it changes. Looking for the overall pattern is the challenge. We find there are often patterns within patterns.

I'm attaching some pdf's here with a basic lesson plan and some charts you might want to use as you collect data to help you look for patterns in the numbers that will guide your predictions.

Here's the link to pdf: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1_55YxwMyGFFT8FKgbLVN85RKDHNIiSkj/view?usp=sharing

Have fun! Take your time with this one.

All the best,
Bob

This activity is based on an idea originally published in Teaching Children Mathematics, a publication of the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM).

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What Does Not Belong?

 Hi All,   "What Does Not Belong" is such a great little concept and can be applied to so many different areas of math as well as other content areas. Great little game when you are waiting, like for buses to be called or for the day to begin. Also a great game for long car or bus rides where if there are no written numbers or pictures you really have to do the mental math. Present a group of numbers. Start with maybe six. Say, 10     56     17     122     4     98 Ask the players to identify which number does not belong and have them explain why. We want players to look at the characteristics of the numbers and compare them to try to find the selection criteria or "rule" so they can determine which does not belong. For example, we have a mix of 1, 2, and 3 digit numbers, so it's not the "rule" is not the number of digits. We have five even numbers and only one odd number. That's it! 17 does not belong,...

Piaget Would be Proud! Assessment, Mental Math, Manipulatives, Thinking, Missing Addends, and Kumquats!

 Hi All, This is a super simple, but very revealing activity and so works as a good assessment. Fantastic for Pre-K, Kindergarten, and Grade 1. Try it out and see what you learn about your students. Display a small number of objects in your open hands. Here we have 4 kumquats. (Because I have a kumquat tree in my yard. Any small manipulative will do.) Put your hands behind your back. Close one hand and bring both hands back out in front of you to display 2 kumquats visible in one hand and a closed hand with the rest of them. Remind students that you started with 4 and there are still 4 all together. Ask students, what is in the closed hand. Ask how they know this. Then reveal and discuss. Try another one. Show the 4 objects again, 2 in each hand. Put your hands behind your back and redistribute with 1 object in one hand and 3 objects in the other. Bring your hands to the front and ask how many are in your closed hand. Ask how they know this.  Then reveal and discuss.   Yo...

Calculator Caller!

Hi All, I had a colleague I taught with for years. She was a passionate second grade teacher with a lot of solid experience. A parent once asked her, "What is the most important thing you can teach a child?" I was thinking that's a tough question. Maybe, to treat others like you would treat yourself? Her immediate reply was, "Place value." Ha, ha! She was a real math maven! Place value is important though! Here's one fun partner activity that gives kids practice with calculators (which they need in standardized tests as well as real life), place value, number recognition, and number words. It's motivating because most kids love to get their hands on calculators and as teachers and parents we're usually telling them, "No calculators!"   1. Each player gets a calculator and a recording sheet. The lead player decides on a number, inputs it into his calculator, writes it down on the record sheet, says it aloud, but does not let his partner se...